I’ve been a champion for microcaps for the whole of my investing career. My affinity for undervalued, smaller capitalized stocks in large drove the success I have had investing in the stock market since the late 1980’s. If you are a large cap investor, you mostly likely have not noticed that microcap investors over the course of the last several years had become disenfranchised due to the investment community’s overall lack of trust in the space, thus making it more of an impotent investment option for portfolio-driven wealth seekers, until now.
For me and other avid microcap investors, being a proponent of microcaps has kind of been like rooting for your home team. You always wear their jersey, regardless of their record, through the peaks and valleys, wins and losses. You stand by your conviction that you’ve made the right choice to stay the path even though at times things may look hopeless or bleak. You witness one group jumping ship from your team to the crowd favorite, while yet another group scoffs at your undying commitment.
Planet Microcap with Robert Kraft
Things are changing. To convey my position on the state of microcaps, I once again had a chance to speak with Robert Kraft of Planet Microcap, someone with whom I’ve developed a good relationship, given our mutual “team spirit.” He had me revisiting some of the fundamental reasons why I continue to favor microcap stocks, and picked my brain on some of the catalysts that have recently driven these stocks to healthily outperform the major indices.
He was already aware that in 2015 I thought that the micocap space was starting to heat up, but even leading into the first half of 2016, the stocks that I followed were not living up to their potentials. It was taking a lot of time for stocks to react to good news, and the lack of liquidity in microcaps resulted in very muted performance profiles.
To say that being a stock picker in the microcaps has been challenging is an understatement. Time horizons for investors have gotten a lot shorter. In the years prior to 2008, investors may have held stocks for up to 6 and a half years, while today that time horizon might be less than 6 months. Add to that the volatility and general broad skepticism, and you get less money being invested in microcaps.
- Real Estate Dividend Stock On Our Radar: Limited Downside and 58% Discount to Book Value
- Here’s Why I Finally Took a Long Position in The Eastern Company (EML)
- Could This Speculative Information Arbitrage Play Be Worth An 8 Times Current Price?
But things started to change during the last half of 2016, after the British exit from the EU, aptly (and for the sake of the press) named Brexit. A rotation of money into microcaps started to occur after it became evident that these stocks did not react as negatively to the event as larger cap companies that are exposed to global risks during what ended up being a post-Brexit 5% pull back.
However, microcaps were not yet out of the water. There was still a capitulation of sorts prior to the US Presidential election that saw large percentage drops in some microcap stocks, with uncertainty taking front stage as the nation teetered between two candidates whose views couldn’t be farther apart from one another. The experts implied that a Trump win would decimate the market. Heck, I heard it so many times that even I started to believe it. It was hard not to be cynical given the voice that I had whole-heartedly adopted over the course of the last several years calling for a much-awaited microcap revival that had still yet to fully surface.
Microcaps Finally Living Up to Their Potential?
Of course, now that you’ve seen what happened with the smaller indexes such as iShares Micro-Cap (IWC) and iShares Russell 2000 (IWM) after the election, we can with some degree of confidence attribute this historic market rise to the domestic policy overhaul that Trump wants to implement across the board. Companies are even holding their gains and starting to raise money – a very healthy sign that fundamental investment has once again entered the picture. I am optimistic that this trend has the potential to continue into 2017. Even though over the last couple of years it has been an overall tough time to be a full-time microcap investor, a survey I recently published on Twitter illustrates that there is interest in these stocks, a near 50/50 split, and a stark contrast to decreased popularity that has plagued the space.
— Maj Soueidan (@majgeoinvesting) December 9, 2016
Robert was curious as to how I gauged the health of the market. I tend not to complicate things, staying away from technical triggers for the most part. In my view, a healthy market is one that consists of good earnings reports and investors who find and pick up shares in these companies. There are positive reactions to healthy fundamentals. In other words, investors care about the health and outlook of the companies they are investing in. Imagine that.
Of course, we’ve seen stocks with no technical issues to speak of accrue healthy gains over the course of longer periods of time, only to lose most of those gains in a few days. So as much as it pains me, it goes without saying that this is enough reason to maintain a guarded attitude towards the space, and even the market as a whole.
Reversion to the mean
— Maj Soueidan (@majgeoinvesting) February 6, 2016
History has shown us the word “forever” won’t be found in any investment dictionary. When things seem bad, you can count on a catalyst to turn things around. In the case of microcaps, we expect safe money to flow into the space in the face of chaotic global triggers – oil price uncertainty, currency fluctuations, interest rate hikes – most of which are bad for larger caps’ balance sheets.
It would have been nice to see increased stability, excitement and institutional investments come into microcaps a little earlier in the transition from 2015 to 2016. Heading into mid-2016, we started to see private equity firms and hedge funds, who are typically activists investing in larger caps, make their way down the food chain to smaller companies. This tells you that eventually, undervaluation does not go unnoticed. On a positive note, this gives microcaps steam going into 2017 as I strongly believe that we will see these firms play a bigger role in the companies that I, my company and my peers follow. When merger activity becomes evident, and I believe this is a real possibility, this is when the true representation of value will come to light in some undiscovered and underfollowed microcaps.
It drives me crazy when companies mismanage their businesses and don’t treat shareholders the way they should. Companies that have winning characteristics have management teams that understand how to run their businesses and can clearly communicate this to their investors. The maximization of shareholder value comes naturally in the process of running the company responsibly. Companies like this should fare well in any market environment. Take for example a company that performs well in an underperforming sector. Much of this can be attributed to transparency and communication, and I am more than happy to take advantage of this kind of opportunity – frankly, it sets me apart from others who will ignore an entire industry based on the sector’s performance. On the flip side, even though I tend to be a company-specific stock picker, I won’t shy away from reaping some of the benefits an entire sector might see from a changing economic landscape. GeoInvesting’s infrastructure portfolios did quite well, even before Trump won the election. Industry trends will always play a consistent role in the way I and my team look for broader opportunities. If played right, this strategy can transform a portfolio.
There are also many ways social media can now play a part in how a company interacts with shareholders. Companies that understand this to be advantageous will have an edge over others that are behind the media curve. Just look at Trump – his blueprint for using Twitter as a platform to boost his voter reach arguably helped to put him over the top, and certainly led to him spending a fraction of the money that Hillary Clinton spent on her campaign.
If there’s any one thing investors can glean from the year that 2016 was, it’s that unpredictable events can get you caught with your pants down. So, in 2017 I look forward to doing what I am best at and have always done – Invest in companies based on what I know and learn so I can predict the unpredictable.
My interview with Robert Kraft can be heard below, in its entirety. The above commentary is an extension and reiteration of many of the views and opinions expressed in my interview with him.
I’m also excited about and looking forward to the 2017 Microcap Conference Panel in Las Vegas. Chris Irons, one of GeoInvesting’s lead analysts, plans to be there with me.
- Remembering Marty Whitman – Deep Value Portfolio Manager
- Behavioral Finance Is Central To Value Investing
- BlueLinx Holdings Case Study – How We Nailed Attractive Entry Point In Shares of This Building Supply Company
- Five Inspiring Investors And Their Contributions To Value Investing
- Transcript – Andrew W. Lo on “Adaptive Markets: Financial Evolution at the Speed of Thought”
- Change Has Made Us Better, Improving Our Investment Products Is At The Forefront
- Change Has Made Us Better, Improving Our Stock Research Service Is At The Forefront
- Understanding Zoned Properties’ Business: CEO Bryan McLaren on Triple-Net-Leasing, Legislation and Community Relationships
- Gridsum CEO Guosheng Qi On Understanding The Company’s Unique Business Position In Big Data
- I’m A Bull At Heart, But I Have To Keep It Real